Reindeer Grill

Stephanie Whitesel

3 years ago

This was our first visit and we will definitely be coming back. We had the cream of crab soup (I'll be getting the bowl next time!), beef lasagna, and fish and chips. The lasagna was great, generous portion size and the garlic knots were delicious. The crab soup had lots of crab in it and the fries were some of the best we've had from any restaurant. Our server Jamie was so sweet and friendly. Food came quickly.

Anna Payne

6 months ago

This place is a staple for a mid-ohio trip. Great food quality. Perfect service. Really positive experience every time we go there. The crab balls and chicken pot pie are absolutely incredible. Garlic knots are great too!

Missy Keck

4 years ago

This was my first time here the food was delicious and the service was fantastic. Jamie was our waitress, and helped guide us through our selections and there were garlic knots when we first sat down. We did a bowl of cream of crab soup and the crab balls (both with huge lumps of crab in them ) as an appetizer. They were both better than anything we got at the ocean. I hardly ever talk about the drinks but the sweet tea was perfect. Then came the sandwich (turkey reuben) I had a bite of the hubby's sandwich it was great. Then I dove into my Philly Mac and cheese (we had chicken instead of steak.) I loved it. Best Mac and cheese I've had in forever. Here's the kicker.... it's all homemade. Can't wait to go back and try couple other things. The carrot cake we got to go and ate at home was good. Not to many spices and coconut with cream cheese icing ... yummy.. hope u all 😉 enjoy.

Tony Skeans

3 years ago

We came to town for a catch up visit with old friends and to enjoy what small city Ohio has to offer. I expected good, but got great. We choose this place based upon the Google Maps rating and I was not disappointed. The location is convenient, located on the main square of the town near the court house, there was a jazz band playing in the square and people walking around so nice vibe. The place was small and well used so we knew on walking in it had a potential far beyond the ordinary small town diner. All I can say after eating there is WOW! I’ve eaten at places with three times the price point and half the food and been happy. The food and the service knocked my socks off. The garlic knots were sublime and the marinara sauce served with them was as good as I make at home. Our food was served quick and all was exactly right. The biggest crime of the day is that we ordered the mash potatoes for the baby in the group while we had adult food. We took the leftovers home for a later feeding. On warming them up I sampled them to make sure the temperature was right and I can say I have never had mashed potatoes from a restaurant any where as good as they were and that was after 24 hours in the fridge. Go for the fancy food but make sure your get the mashed taters for later!

Curt Cunning

year ago

Came here with the wife, and was very satisfied. The feel is definitely small town grill, but not in a bad way. It felt very comfy. The service was excellent and made us feel like family friends. Got the buffalo chicken pizza with a salad, and the garlic knots... The pizza was brilliant, and oh man, the garlic knots. Highly recommended. Lastly, we got a cookie with ice cream and it was decadent. This is a place we plan to come back to often.

Logan Tilley

11 months ago

Stopped in while passing through town, knew nothing about the place outside of seeing they were open. Service was fast and very friendly, prices were veryy fair, especially for the portion sizes. All the food my family got was delicious and very filling. Definitely needed a togo box. I feel bad I don't remember the servers name but he was working today, the 4th and was very polite and attentive. Would go back.

Bianca

year ago

We were in the area visiting from Arizona and really found ourselves a true hidden gem with Reindeer Grill! It’s a small spot, serving up BIG flavors. EVERYTHING was amazing! 10/10 We started with the chicken quesadilla which was loaded with cheese and chicken, super good. Our entrees were the Prime Rib, Lasagna, Chicken Alfredo and also a small pepperoni and sausage pizza. The flavors in all of these dishes were super powerful and everything was steamy hot freshly made! This place deserves 5+ starts. Wish it wasn’t so far from Az or we would be here every week! No matter what you’re in the mood for, this amazing little spot has it! The pastas were better than any Italian restaurants we’ve ever been to from coast to coast! The quality of the pizza toppings and homemade crust, unexplainable. And let’s not forget the garlic knots! Baked fresh, loaded with flavor and accompanied with marinara sauce. Now for the dessert. How can every single item on the menu be so amazing?!! The carrot cake and the “cookie monster” desserts, BEST EVER! The frosting and moistness of the carrot cake was just perfection, and the freshly baked cookie in the small cast-iron dish with amazing vanilla ice cream, doesn’t get any better than this. Lastly, we would like to thank our server James!!! The world needs more amazing humans like James. He took such great care of us. He was very very nice, attentive and polite. Thank you for making our experience even more great!!

william burger jr

9 months ago

We were in the area for a relatives special party and picked the Reindeer Grill at random. It's a special little spot in Mansfield that has a unique name and setup. The complimentary garlic knots are fantastic. My steak dinner came with a choice of salad, I picked Ceaser salad which was a chopped salad, that made it better than anything other salad I have gotten anywhere else. The steak dinner was delicious. My wife ordered the Seafood Alfredo, she was a little disappointed with that; said it didn't have a rich Alfredo sauce and not as much of a seafood mix that she was expecting. The service was outstanding.

Jordan Clark

2 months ago

Went for a quick lunch. Stayed for the food that just kept coming. Great service. Reasonably priced. Great portion sizes. Restaurant has a big island split in the middle nothing of their fault. I love that worship music was played.

Tina Fiore

month ago

This is a nice quiet restaurant and I must say the added touch of the Red Peppers in the garden salad elevated the whole thing when you add on the House Made Cesar Dressing that is the real chefs kiss!!! The garlic knots are delicious having 2 complimentary is the perfect hook to higher sales because once you taste them you will need more! I was pleasantly surprised to find lasagna made with Ground Beef and it did not disappoint! My hubby had the Seafood Alfredo and he said it was quite tasty!